Male Superstars
| Superstar | Star Level | PSN ID | Held Since |
 AJ Styles | All Rounder | NeMeSiS850 | Season 1 |
 Akira Tozawah | Mid-Card | - | - |
 Austin Theory | Mid-Card | KrazyJ20 | Season 6 |
 Big E | All Rounder | TripleX2600 | Season 6 |
 Bobby Lashley | All Rounder | - | Season 5 |
 Braun Strowman | All Rounder | FOXGOD2217 | Season 6 |
 Bray Wyatt DLC | MAIN EVENT | - | Season 6 |
 Cedric Alexander | Mid-Card | - | |
 Cody Rhodes | All Rounder | BritishHeel | Season 6 |
 Damien Priest | Mid-Card | Jasonleech0007 | - |
 Dexter Lumis | Mid-Card | Biel_Ares | Season 6 |
 Dolph Ziggler | All Rounder | - | - |
 Dominick Mysterio | Mid-Card | - | Season 5 |
 Drew Gulak | Mid-Card | - | - |
 Drew McIntyre | MAIN EVENT | LWOLF1 | Season 6 |
 Edge | MAIN EVENT | xXTHESHOWSTOPPER | Season 5 |
 Elias | Mid-Card | - | Season 5 |
 Finn Balor | All Rounder | BigRicky04 | Season 6 |
 Gunther | All Rounder | shadowvoltreXx | Season 6 |
 Happy Corbin | Mid-Card | - | Season 5 |
 Johnny Gargano | Mid-Card | Season 5 | |
 Karrion Kross | All Rounder | Kirb_Stomp__ | Season 6 |
 Kevin Owens | All Rounder | DBS_MEntality | Season 5 |
 LA Knight | Mid-Card | TeddyBearZilla | Season 6 |
 Logan Paul | All Rounder | DonnaMc27 | Season 6 |
 Madcap Moss | Mid-Card | - | - |
 Mustafa Ali | Mid-Card | - | - |
 MVP | Mid-Card | - | - |
 Omos | All Rounder | - | - |
 R-Truth | Mid-Card | - | - |
 Randy Orton | All Rounder | TYCzWrld | Season 1 |
 Rey Mysterio | All Rounder | - | Season 6 |
 Ricochet | Mid-Card | - | - |
 Rick Boogs | Mid-Card | - | |
 Riddle | All Rounder | xForty9ersx | Season 6 |
 Robert Roode | Mid-Card | - | Season 5 |
 Roman Reigns | MAIN EVENT | edd4q2 | Season 4 |
 Sami Zayn | All Rounder | Sku11Crusher3106 | Season 3 |
 Santos Escobar | Mid-Card | - | Season 6 |
 Seth Rollins | All Rounder | LeBryan_James23 | Season 4 |
 Sheamus | All Rounder | xSlickRevengex | Season 5 |
 Shelton Benjamin | Mid-Card | - | - |
 Shinsuke Nakamura | All Rounder | - | - |
 Solo Sikoa | Mid-Card | BubbaSparkz19 | - |
 The Miz | All Rounder | NicoleR16 | - |
 Titus O'Neil | Mid-Card | - | |
 Tomasso Ciampa | Mid-Card | - | Season 6 |
Female Superstars
| Superstar | PSN ID | Held Since |
 Alba Fyre | BubbaSparkz17 | Season 6 |
 Alexa Bliss | DonnaMc27 | Season 5 |
 Aliyah | - | - |
 Asuka | BigRicky04 | Season 3 |
 Bayley | NicoleR16 | Season 5 |
 Becky Lynch | DBS_MEntality | Season 1 |
 Bianca Belair | xXTHESHOWSTOPPER | Season 5 |
 Blair Davenport DLC | Kirb_Stomp__ (2) | Season 6 |
 Carmella | Sku11Crusher3106 | Season 6 |
 Charlotte Flair | NeMeSiS850 | Season 1 |
 Cora Jade | LWOLF1 | Season 6 |
 Dana Brooke | - | Season 6 |
 Dakota Kai | FOXGOD2217 | Season 6 |
 Doudrop | KrazyJ20 | Season 6 |
 Gigi Dolin | NeMeSiS850 (2) | Season 6 |
 Iyo Sky | Kirb_Stomp__ | Season 6 |
 Indi Hartwell | TeddyBearZilla | Season 5 |
 Ivy Nile DLC | - | - |
 Jacy Jayne | - | Season 6 Switch |
 Katana Chance | - | - |
 Kayden Carter | - | - |
 Lacey Evans | - | - |
 Liv Morgan | LeBryan_James23 | Season 6 |
 Natalya | - | - |
 Nikki Kross | - | - |
 Nikkita Lyons | - | Season 6 |
 Raquel Rodriguez | Biel_Ares | Season 6 |
 Rhea Ripley | xSlickRevengex | Season 6 |
 Ronda Rousey | edd4q2 | Season 6 |
 Roxanne Perez | DBS_MEntality (2) | Season 6 |
 Shayna Baszler | BubbaSparkz17 (2) | Season 6 |
 Shotzi | xSlickRevengex | Season 6 |
 Sonya Deville | - | Season 5 |
 Tamina | - | - |
 Tiffany Stratton DLC | shadowvoltreXx | Season 6 |
 Valhalla DLC | - | - |
 Wendy Choo DLC | - | - |
 Xia Lee | Jasonleech0007 | Season 5 |
 Zelina Vega | xXTHESHOWSTOPPER (2) | Season 6 |
 Zoey Stark | LeBryan_James23 (2) | Season 6 |
Tag Teams
| Team Name | Superstar | PSN ID | Superstar | PSN ID | Faction Members |
| Alpha Academy |  Chad Gable | xSlickRevengex |  Otis | xXTHESHOWSTOPPER | - |
| Brawling Brutes |  Butch | - |  Ridge Holland | - | Sheamus (L) |
| Creed Brother |  Brutus Creed | - |  Julius Creed | - | |
| Imperium |  Giovanni Vinci | Biel_Ares |  Ludwig Kaiser | LeBryan_James23 | Gunther (L) |
| Hit Row DLC |  Ashante | - |  Top Dolla | - | B-Fab (M) |
| Legado Del Fantasma |  Cruz Del Toro | - |  Joaquin Wilde | - | Santos Escobar (L) Zelina Vega (M) |
| Maximum Male Models |  MA.CE | - |  MAN.SOOR | - | |
| Pretty Deadly DLC |  Kit Wilson | - |  Elton Prince | - | |
| Street Profits |  Angelo Dawkins | edd4q2 |  Montez Ford | NeMeSiS850 | - |
| The Usos The Blood Line |  Jey Uso | DBS_MEntality |  Jimmy Uso | TheYeetersClub | Roman Reigns (L) Solo Sikoa Paul Heyman(M) |
| The Good Brothers Original Club DLC |  Karl Anderson | xForty9ersx |  Luke Gallows | TeddyBearZilla | AJ Styles (L) |
| Viking Raiders |  Erik | - |  Ivar | - | Valhalla (M) |
| The Letharios |  Angel | - |  Humberto | - | - |
| The New Day |  Kofi Kingston | NicoleR16 |  Xavier Woods | DonnaMc27 | Big E |
| Superstar | Star Level | PSN ID |
 Apollo Crews | - | Sku11crusher3106 |
 Axiom | - | LWOLF1 |
 Azeez | - | - |
 Bron Breaker | - | xXTHESHOWSTOPPER |
 Cameron Grimes | - | Kirb_Stomp__ |
 Carmelo Hayes | - | TeddyBearZilla |
 Damon Kemp DLC | - | - |
 Grayson Waller | - | Jasonleech0007 GM Pick |
 Ilja Dragunov | - | NicoleR16 |
 JD McDonagh | - | xForty9ersx |
 Joe Gacy DLC | - | - |
 Jinder Mahal | - | FOXGOD2217 |
 Noam Dar | - | - |
 Nathan Frazer DLC | - | - |
 Reggie | - | - |
 Shanky | - | - |
 T-Bar | - | edd4q2 |
 Tony D'Angelo DLC | - | - |
 Trick Williams DLC | - | - |
 Tyler Bate | - | DonnaMc27 |
 Veer Mahaan | - | - |
 Wes Lee | - | BubbaSparkz19 |